More troops or Smithy upgrades?

One of the most frequent questions a lot of new (and quite some veteran) players ask themselves are at which point they should start smithy upgrades of the units in order to benefit most from attack/defence/scout action?

Today we answer this question! In the table below you will find after how many troops it’s most efficient to upgrade the units rather that traning new.


Some notes:

  • We take into account only upgrade costs, not smithy construction costs. If you want to take this into account, the number should be a bit higher then.
  • For scouts we take “Scout attack” value (35) and “Scout resistance” value (20) instead of attack and defence. Those values are same for all tribes’ scout units, however, Smithy upgrades make them a bit different.
  • For example, 2-crop-consuming units are a bit more effective than 1-crop-consuming after upgrades due to the smithy upgrade formula, but for defence 1-crop-units (scouts, sentinels) are more preferable.


Smithy upgrade tables for the each tribe:

ROMANS

TEUTONS

GAULS

HUNS

EGYPTIANS

SPARTANS

VIKINGS


The P.S. Google sheet form of the same table can be found here.

Did you find it helpful? Yes No

Send feedback
Sorry we couldn't be helpful. Help us improve this article with your feedback.